Judgment Day

Judgment Day — Love78 writing archive

In a heavenly courtroom, an anxious defendant learns what it means to trust his advocate.

An imaginative courtroom allegory about sin, repentance and grace. The complete screenplay is presented as a script, with the original PDF available below.

Reader note: Death, adultery and domestic abuse.

View or download the original PDF

Read the screenplay: Judgment Day

FADE IN:

EXT. CITY STREET -- DAY

INTERCUT scenes of a man call him JOHN SMITH walking down a
busy city street with a truck coming up out of an alley and
the driver talking on his cell phone. As this is happening
SUPERIMPOSE Creative Diversions Present. HOLD for a BEAT.
SUPERIMPOSE A Patrick R. Aquilone Film. John approaches
the corner and walks out without noticing that the driver
of the truck is too busy talking to see the red light. The
camera ANGLE ON up towards the sky and we hear a thud and
go to.

EXT. HEAVEN (CGI) -- DAY

First we see clouds SUPERIMPOSE Judgment Day. HOLD for a
BEAT. Then we pass over a stereotypical Looking heaven.
The clouds, the gold street. SUPERIMPOSE Starring... HOLD
for a BEAT. We began to slowly PUSH IN on a large building
at the end of the golden highway. We PUSH IN on the doors
of the large building which has the words on it HALL OF
JUSTICE.

                                                DISSOLVE TO:

INT. HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

A somewhat typically looking courtroom (subject to location
and materials available). There is an audience that
consists mostly of people waiting for there case to be
called (subject to courtroom location). We see John now
dressed in a suit pacing near the defendants table looking
back toward the doors to the room. SUPERIMPOSE Directed
by Patrick R. Aquilone. HOLD for a BEAT.

                                                     CUT TO:

P.O.V. JOHN SMITH -- DAY
As the camera pans around we see a man in a suit at the
prosecution table call him LUCIFER. Lucifer is standing.
He opens his briefcase and pulls out a rather large case
file. He sits down opens the file and gives an evil smile
toward John.

                                                     CUT TO:

CU ON JOHN SMITH

John's eye grow big and he looks back at the door as we

                                                     CUT TO:

INT. FULL SHOT HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

We see a man call him JESUS CHRIST entering the courtroom
dressed in a suit. John looks agitated. We see Jesus
enter the courtroom and walk over to the defense table.

ON JOHN SMITH

                    JOHN SMITH
              (nervous)
          Oh, Jesus, I am glad you are here.

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (calm)
          John, I would not let you down.

                    JOHN SMITH
          I know, but the last case. Jesus, the
          guy was a saint compared to me. He was
          even an active member of the Peace Corp
          and he still got sent to hell, the
          death penalty.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          Relax, John. I wasn't asked to defend
          the man in the last case, but I have
          been asked to defend you. There is
          nothing to worry about.

                    JOHN SMITH
          I know, but the Judge
              (sigh HOLD for a BEAT)
          He was very intimidating.

                    JESUS CHRIST
             I know he can be, but it will be all
             right. Trust me.

                       JOHN SMITH
                 (still nervous, but trying to
                  be calm)
             Alright.

A man in uniform walks forward from the corner of the room.
This is the court BAILIFF.

ON BAILIFF

                         BAILIFF
             All rise.

FULL SHOT HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

Everyone stands up as the JUDGE GOD THE FATHER enters the
room.

CLOSEUP ON JUDGE

                       BAILIFF
             The court will come to order. The
             honorable GOD THE FATHER presiding.

                        GOD THE FATHER
                 (sits)
             Be seated.

FULL SHOT HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

Everyone sits down.

                       GOD THE FATHER
                 (beat)
             Bailiff.

                       BAILIFF
             Case number 777-71292, God's Law verses
             JOHN SMITH.

The Bailiff hands a folder to God the Father.       God the
Father looks down and begins to read it.

ON LUCIFER AND JESUS CHRIST

                         LUCIFER
              (Stands.)
          Lucifer for the prosecution, your
          honor.

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (No briefcase or folder. Very
               calm and respectful.)
          Jesus Christ for the defense, your
          honor.

CLOSEUP GOD THE FATHER

God the Father still looking down half looks up at Jesus
and allows a small smile to be seen. HOLD for a BEAT it is
important that we see the smile. Then we go to

INT. FULL SHOT HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

                    GOD THE FATHER
          How does the defendant plead?

                    JESUS CHRIST
          Not guilty, your honor.

John Smith is still standing respectfully, but his hands
are shaking.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Very well, Lucifer are you ready to
          begin.

                    LUCIFER
          I am your honor.

                     GOD THE FATHER
          Proceed.

CLOSEUP LUCIFER

                    LUCIFER
              (stands up and begins to walk
               out between the judges bench
               and the counsel tables.
               Lucifer addresses God the
               Father as well as the entire
               court.)
          The prosecution will show beyond a
          shadow of a doubt that John Smith
              (points toward John Smith)
          Is guilt of several, not one, not a
          couple, but several acts of sinful
          disobedient behavior against God's Law.
          We will also show that Mr. Smith
          committed all of these acts knowing
          full well that they were wrong making
          his sins all the more hideous. Mr.
          Smith is a menace to himself as well as
          to what this court stands for. It is
          because of these crimes that we will
          seek the maximum penalty for Mr. Smith,
          eternity in hell.

Lucifer walks back over and sits down.   HOLD for a BEAT.

ON GOD THE FATHER

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Jesus, your opening arguments.

CLOSEUP JESUS CHRIST

                    JESUS CHRIST
          Thank you, your honor.
              (Jesus stands up and also
               walks out in front of the
               Judges bench and addresses
               God the Father and the
               courtroom.)
          John Smith has no doubt lived an
          interesting life that has been laced
          with questionable acts of sin.
              (BEAT)
          However, John Smith is no different
          than any other member of the human
          race. Further, he has committed his
          life to becoming a sold out follower of
          exactly what this court stands for. I
          do not believe that the prosecution
          knows John Smith like I do. Your honor
          it is that John Smith that I believe in
          the end
              (Looks briefly back at
               Lucifer)
          Beyond a shadow of a doubt, will set
          him free. It is my intention to show
          this court that John Smith.
                    LUCIFER
              (snickers and speaks under his
               breath)
          Yeah, right.

Jesus returns to his seat.   HOLD for a BEAT.

FULL SHOT HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Prosecution call your first witness.

                    LUCIFER
              (stands)
          I call Evelyn Smith to the stand.

John is visibly agitated.

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (leans and whisper)
          Don't worry it will be all right.

Evelyn Smith walks up and takes the stand.    The Bailiff
walks over and holds up a book.

                    BAILIFF
          Raise your right hand.

Evelyn raises her hand and places her left hand on the
bible.

                    BAILIFF (CONT'D)
          Do you swear to tell the truth, the
          whole truth and nothing but the truth
          so help you God.

                    EVELYN SMITH
          I do.

The Bailiff returns to his station and Evelyn sits down.

                     LUCIFER
              (stands up and approaches the
               witness stand)
          Mrs. Smith would you please inform the
          court what your relation is to the
          defendant.

                    EVELYN SMITH
          Yes, he is my son.
              (Evelyn smiles and waves at
               John)

John sighs and shakes his head.    Jesus places his hand on
John's back.

                    LUCIFER
          Mrs. Smith would you say that John is a
          good son?

                    EVELYN SMITH
              (smiling)
          Yes, yes I would. He was always so
          helpful.

                    LUCIFER
              (sarcastic)
          Yes, I am sure he is.
              (accusatory)
          Yet on March 7, 1983 did he not tell
          you that he thought your husband was a
          coward?

                    EVELYN SMITH
          Well...

                    LUCIFER
          I remind you that you are under oath to
          tell the truth.

                    EVELYN SMITH
              (visibly upset)
          Yes, he did, but...

                    LUCIFER
          Mrs. Smith wouldn't you consider that
          to be an unfair judgment of your
          husband's character.

                    EVELYN SMITH
          Yes, but John didn't...

                    LUCIFER
          Simple yes or no will do Mrs. Smith.
              (Lucifer turns slowly walking
               toward his seat with his back
               to the witness stand)
          Mrs. Smith in your understanding of
          God's Law that this court is based on
              (he turns to face Mrs. Smith)
          Wouldn't that be a sin?

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (stands)
          Objection, the witness is not an expert
          on God's Law.

                    LUCIFER
          True, but she is aware of what she
          taught her son to believe about the law
          lending to the defendants state of
          mind.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          I'll allow it.

Jesus sits back down.

                     LUCIFER
               (Small evil smile can be seen
                on his face)
          Mrs. Smith wouldn't that kind of
          judgment in your understanding be a
          sin?

                    EVELYN SMITH
          Yes.
              (Puts her head down)
          Yes, it would.

                    LUCIFER
          No further questions your honor.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Jesus, do you wish to cross examine?

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (stands)
          Yes, I do your honor.
              (walks toward Evelyn)
          Mrs. Smith why did John call your
          husband a coward?

                    EVELYN SMITH
Well, our next door neighbor, Fred, had
been having problems in his marriage.
To make matters worse, his wife kept
comparing him to Paul, my husband.
Well, one day during a particularly bad
fight, Fred stormed over to the house
and marched up and punched Paul right
in the face. Paul refuse to fight
back. John witnessed the whole thing
and that is why he called Paul a
coward.

          JESUS CHRIST
Mrs. Smith would you please tell me
what came of Paul's actions that day?

          EVELYN SMITH
Yes, Fred could not believe that Paul
did not react and lash back. About a
month later, Fred came over and asked
to speak to Paul. The two went into
the garage and Paul told me that Fred
became a Christian that day.

          JESUS CHRIST
And Mrs. Smith when did you find out
all the information about your
neighbor's marrital problems?

          EVELYN SMITH
It wasn't until after that day in the
garage. We began to counsel them.

          JESUS CHRIST
So, then would it be fair to say that
John might have known something was up,
but had no idea the depth of the
problem?

          EVELYN SMITH
Yes.

           JESUS CHRIST
Thank you.
    (turns toward God the Father)
No further questions your honor.

          GOD THE FATHER
          The witness is excused.

Evelyn Smith steps down from the witness stand.   As she
walks past the defense table she speaks.

                    EVELYN SMITH
          I'm sorry John.

                    JOHN SMITH
              (half smile)
          Don't worry, mom. Jesus has everything
          under control.

Evelyn continues walking out as John turns to Jesus.

                     JOHN SMITH (CONT'D)
              (whisper)
          You do have everything under control
          don't you?

                    JESUS CHRIST
          John, trust me, you have nothing to
          worry about.

ON GOD THE FATHER

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Prosecution call your next witness.

                    LUCIFER
              (Standing)
          The prosecution calls Robert
          Brinkerhoff to the stand.

Again John is agitated. Robert Brinkerhoff enters the
courtroom and walks to the witness stand. The Bailiff
walks over and holds up a book.

                    BAILIFF
          Raise your right hand.

Robert raise his hand and places the left on the Bible.

                    BAILIFF (CONT'D)
          Do you swear to tell the truth, the
          whole truth and nothing but the truth
          so help you God.

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          I do.

CLOSEUP LUCIFER

                     LUCIFER
              (walking to the witness stand)
          Mr. Brinkerhoff how do you know the
          defendant?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          He is married to my sister.

                    LUCIFER
          And would you say he has been a good
          brother-in-law to you?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          He is the only one I have so I don't
          have anything else to compare him too.

                    LUCIFER
          I see. Then would you say, in your
          opinion, he is a good man?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          Well, I am not sure.

                    LUCIFER
          What do you mean?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          Well, he hasn't exactly been a model
          citizen.

                    LUCIFER
          What happened during the summer of
          1997?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          John had an affair with my wife.

                    LUCIFER
              (looks back at John)
          Really,
              (turns and walks slowly
               towards John)
          the man that Jesus knows and wishes to
          show to this court is an adulterer?
                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          Yeah.

                    LUCIFER
              (evil smile and looks directly
               at Jesus)
          Well, well, I guess we really are
          getting to know
              (deeper sarcastic tone)
          the real John Smith.
              (turns back towards Robert)
          So, he had an affair with his own
          brother-in-law's wife?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          Yeah, he did.

                    LUCIFER
          What were the consequence of this
          affair?

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          Jennifer and I got a divorce and I
          haven't spoken to John since.

                     LUCIFER
              (Lucifer fakes a sad look on
               his face)
          But he is married to your sister.    I
          bet that made family gatherings
          difficult.

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          Well, I pretty much stopped going to
          them and have barely spoken with my
          sister since.

                    LUCIFER
          All this because pretty boy over there
          couldn't keep his pants on.
              (turns towards the judge)
          Sad. Really sad. No further questions
          your honor.

Lucifer returns to his seat.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Jesus, do you wish to cross-examine?
          JESUS CHRIST
Yes, your honor.
    (Jesus stands up and walks
     toward the witness stand.)
Mr. Brinkerhoff how did you find out
about this affair?

           ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
John told me about it just before
Christmas.

          JESUS CHRIST
Really, exactly how did he do that?

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
He took me out to lunch and told me how
he and Jennifer had the affair and then
broke it off.

          JESUS CHRIST
Tell me Mr. Brinkerhoff, did he say
anything else during that conversation?

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
Yeah, he asked me to forgive him.

           JESUS CHRIST
Did you?

           ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
     (angry and agitated)
No. Are you kidding, there is no way I
was then or am now going to forgive
him.

          JESUS CHRIST
Why not, don't you love your brother-
in-law?

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
No, I don't. I don't see how he could
love me or my sister and have done what
he did. So, no I don't love him.

          JESUS CHRIST
One last thing, Mr. Smith since the
affair had been broken off for some
months when you found out, exactly why
did Jennifer leave you?

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
She said that she couldn't take my
hitting her anymore.

          JESUS CHRIST
    (surprised but not really)
So you were abusive.

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
    (matter of factly)
Well, only when she got out of line.

          JESUS CHRIST
    (smiling almost laughing.
     Hanging with the guys
     attitude.)
And boy did she know how to step out of
line, didn't she.

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
    (laughing)
She sure did.

          JESUS CHRIST
    (still keeping the hanging
     with the guys attitude)
Hey, why don't you give the court here
an example of just how rebellious of a
wife she could be.

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
Sure thing. There are so many, but I
can remember this one time. I told her
I was going out with guys and she was
to have the house cleaned when I came
back. Do you know what she did?

          JESUS CHRIST
Well, yes, but please tell the court.

          ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
Her sister called and she spent the
whole time talking on the phone. Can
you believe it, I told her to get the
house cleaned.
                    JESUS CHRIST
              (still the attitude)
          Boy, I bet you sure showed her.

                    ROBERT BRINKERHOFF
          I sure did. She wound up in the
          hospital, but she had it coming. And
          when she came home the next day, I made
          her clean the house.

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (facial expression changes to
               one condemnation)
          Yeah, you sure showed her. No further
          questions for this witness, your honor.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          The witness may step down.

The witness begins to walk out of the court. John looks at
him and Robert purposely does not look back at him. We
PUSH in on ECU JOHN SMITH as his face is very sad.

FULL SHOT HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Prosecution call your next witness.

                    LUCIFER
              (Standing)
          The prosecution calls Jane Smith to the
          stand.

Again John is agitated. Jane Smith enters the courtroom
and walks to the witness stand. The Bailiff walks over and
holds up a book.

                    BAILIFF
          Raise your right hand.

Jane raises her hand and places the left on the Bible.

                    BAILIFF (CONT'D)
          Do you swear to tell the truth, the
          whole truth and nothing but the truth
          so help you God.

                    JANE SMITH
          I do.
Jane sits down and Lucifer approaches the witness stand.

                    LUCIFER
          Mrs. Smith...

                    JANE SMITH
          Jane, please.

                    LUCIFER
          Ok, Jane, what is your relationship to
          the defendant?

                    JANE SMITH
          He is my husband.

                    LUCIFER
          Has he been a good husband?

                    JANE SMITH
          Yes, he has. He has always provided
          for me and the kids. He has even gone
          with eating only one meal a day to
          ensure that me and the kids had food.

                     LUCIFER
               (sarcastic)
          Admirable.
               (BEAT. he is now fact
                focused)
          were you aware that John had cheated on
          you?

                    JANE SMITH
          Yes, he told me about it shortly after
          the affair ended.

                    LUCIFER
          And you took him back?

                    JANE SMITH
          Yes, I did. We were having a lot of
          other problems that contributed to him
          feeling like our marriage was over.

                    LUCIFER
          Every marriage has troube, I see to
          that. But not every marriage has
          affairs, so why did you take him back.
          JANE SMITH
I forgave him and believed in him. I
knew that we could repair our marriage.

          LUCIFER
Jane, I am having a bit of trouble
seeing how you believed in a man that
had cheated and lied to you.

          JANE SMITH
    (raises voice)
John is a good man.

          LUCIFER
    (sarcastic)
Really.
    (focused)
But on September 23, 1994, he was not
so
    (sarcastic and accusatory)
Good was he?

           JANE SMITH
Umm.   I am not sure.

          LUCIFER
On September 23, 1994, John, against
your advise, took fifty dollars out of
the offering plate as it was passed
around did he not?

          JANE SMITH
Yes, he did, but...

          LUCIFER
Fifty dollars. Didn't you warn him
that taking the money was stealing from
God?

          JANE SMITH
Yes, but we needed...

          LUCIFER
Jane didn't your husband always tell
your sons to tithe because if they
didn't they were stealing from God?

           JANE SMITH
          Yes. He was good about teaching the
          kids God's word.

                    LUCIFER
          Did your husband tithe off of that
          fifty he stole?

                    JANE SMITH
          I am not sure what you are asking?

                    LUCIFER
          Simple. Did your husband tithe the
          five dollars off of that fifty he took.
          The fifty that God allowed him to have
          out of the offering plate?

                    JANE SMITH
          Well,
              (beat)
          No.

                    LUCIFER
          Then Jane, wouldn't that make him a
          hypocrite as well as a thief?

                    JANE SMITH
          I don't think you understand why he
          took that money...

                    LUCIFER
          Yes or no. Doesn't that make your
          husband, John Smith, a hypocrite and a
          thief as well as an adulterer?

                       JANE SMITH
                 (beat as Jane sighs and bows
                  her head)
          Yes.

                    LUCIFER
          Thank you, Jane. No further questions,
          your honor.

Lucifer returns and sits down.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Jesus do you wish to question the
          witness.
ON JESUS

                     JESUS CHRIST
           Yes, your honor.

                        GOD THE FATHER
           Proceed.

                     JESUS CHRIST
               (stands and walks toward Jane)
           Jane, its ok if I call you Jane?

                     JANE SMITH
               (smiles)
           Oh, yes.

                     JESUS CHRIST
           Jane, why did your husband take that
           fifty dollars?

                     JANE SMITH
           He had been out of work for months and
           we had not become part of the church
           yet. John was convinced that the
           church would not help us so he did the
           only thing he could think of to be able
           to put food on the table for our kids.

                     JESUS CHRIST
           Jane, how did your husband feel about
           taking the money?

                     LUCIFER
           Objection. Jesus isn't actually asking
           her to comment on how her husband felt.

                        GOD THE FATHER
           Sustained.

                     JESUS CHRIST
               (calm, not shaken one bit)
           Jane, can you tell me what your husband
           said to you that night before he went
           to sleep?

                     JANE SMITH
           He said that his stomach was in knots
           and that he felt that he cheated God.
                   JESUS CHRIST
         Jane, what if anything did your husband
         do about taking the money?

                   JANE SMITH
         He went to the church office the next
         day and spoke to the pastor. He told
         me he confessed about the money and the
         Pastor told him it was all right.
         Furthermore the Pastor helped him get
         connected with a man who got him a job.

                   JESUS CHRIST
         That's great. Jane one more thing.
         Did John re-earn your trust as your
         husband after the affair?

                   JANE SMITH
         Yes. We spent a lot of time talking
         about what was wrong with our marriage
         and how we, together would fix it.
         While I was not happy about the affair,
         it opened us up to seek a new depth in
         our marriage.

                   JESUS CHRIST
         So, once again, what Lucifer meant for
         evil, God turned to good.
             (smiling)
         Thank you, Jane. No further questions.

                   GOD THE FATHER
         The witness is excused.

Jane Smith stepped down and walked out. As she passed her
husband, she blows him a kiss. John smiles.

                   GOD THE FATHER (CONT'D)
         Prosecution call your next witness.

                   LUCIFER
         The prosecution calls...

                   JESUS CHRIST
             (stands)
         Your honor, it is my understanding that
         the prosecution intends on calling a
         list of over four thousand people to
          testify that my client has sinned
          against them. We are willing to state
          right now that John Smith has committed
          sins against all of these people.

John becomes visibly agitated again.

                    LUCIFER
              (stands)
          Some of these people John has committed
          multiple sins against and many with the
          full knowledge that he was doing wrong.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          We are willing to so state.

                    GOD THE FATHER
              (looking at Lucifer)
          Good. Then does the prosecution have
          anything else?

                    LUCIFER
              (upset and disrupted)
          No, your honor. The prosecution rests.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          We will take a five minute recess.
              (strikes the gavel)

God the Father gets up and walks out of the courtroom as we
go to

                                                     CUT TO:

INT. HALL OF JUSTICE COUNSEL ROOM -- DAY

John and Jesus walk into a counsel room for the break.
John's hands are shaking and he is visibly upset.

                    JOHN SMITH
          Jesus, don't take this wrong but you
          just handed them the case against me.
              (sits down)
          I'm doomed.

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (sitting down next to John)
          John, calm down. I know what I am
          doing.
                    JOHN SMITH
          Yeah, but all those people. Maybe I
          didn't sin against all of them.

                    JESUS CHRIST
              (smiling)
          John, your talking to Jesus.

                    JOHN SMITH
          I know, but maybe I wasn't aware they
          were all sins.

                       JESUS CHRIST
                 (Still smiling)
          Ahh.

HOLD on Jesus smiling for a BEAT.

                    JOHN SMITH
              (sighs)
          Oh, your right.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          John, you still trust me right.

                    JOHN SMITH
          Of course I do. It's just...

                    JESUS CHRIST
          Then calm down.

                    JOHN SMITH
          Jesus,
              (BEAT)
          I'm scared.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          I know, but don't be. I have
          everything under control.

Jesus puts his arm on John as we go to

                                                        CUT TO:

INT. HALL OF JUSTICE COURTROOM -- DAY

The break is over and everyone is present back in the
courtroom.
                    GOD THE FATHER
          Jesus is the defense ready to proceed
          with its first witness?

                    JESUS CHRIST
          We are your honor.

                       GOD THE FATHER
          Proceed.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          The defense calls John Smith to the
          stand.

John stands up and walks to the witness stand.    The Bailiff
walks over to meet him.

                    BAILIFF
          Raise your right hand.

John raise his hand and his left hand on the Bible.

                    BAILIFF (CONT'D)
          Do you swear to tell the truth, the
          whole truth and nothing but the truth
          so help you God.

                       JOHN SMITH
          I do.

The Bailiff returns.    Jesus walks to the witness stand.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          John you have been accused of some
          pretty nasty crimes against this court.
          Let me ask you, how come you didn't
          plead guilty?

                    JOHN SMITH
          Well, I would have. But when I called
          you for help, you told me that with you
          on my side that I should seek a not
          guilty verdict. So, I just trusted
          you.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          So, then what you are saying is that
          you trusted me with your life.
                       JOHN SMITH
                 (bows head, closes eyes and
                  speak while sighing)
          Yes.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          And because of that you are willing to
          go through this whole ordeal.

                    JOHN SMITH
              (looking back up)
          Yes. I believe that you speak the
          truth and would not lead me astray.
          So, I am doing what you tell me to.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          Thank you, John. No further questions,
          your honor.

Jesus returns to his seat.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Lucifer do you wish to cross examine?

                    LUCIFER
              (speaking with an evil tone
               and smile.)
          Oh, yes I do.
              (Stands)
          So, correct me if I am wrong, but you
          admit that you are guilty of all the
          sins charged against you here?

                       JOHN SMITH
                 (almost a whisper)
          Yes.

                       LUCIFER
          I'm sorry.

                       JOHN SMITH
                 (louder)
          Yes.

                    LUCIFER
          So, you are guilty. You admit it and
          yet somehow you decided to plead not
          guilty. Please tell me how this is not
          a big waste of our time.

                    JOHN SMITH
          I don't know...

                    LUCIFER
          You admit you are guilty. Yet we are
          here why? Because you don't want to be
          sentenced to hell. What's the matter
          can't take the heat.

                    JOHN SMITH
              (Studdering)
          I-I-I...

                    LUCIFER
          But you sure could, when the heat was
          between the sheets with your sister-in-
          law.

                    JOHN SMITH
          Hey, thats not...

                    LUCIFER
              (interrupts)
          Your type sickens me. You should have
          just admitted your guilt with a guilty
          plea and saved everyone a lot of time.

                    JOHN SMITH
              (breaks down crying)
          I admit it. I am a sinner, but when I
          called upon Jesus he told me that he
          will set me free from my sins. All I
          had to do was to trust him.

                    LUCIFER
          You are pathetic expecting to get off
          without your just punishment. I have
          no more questions for this witness,
          your honor.

Lucifer sits down.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          The witness is excused.
John steps down and walks back to his seat.   He is still a
bit shaken. Jesus places his hand on him.

                    GOD THE FATHER (CONT'D)
          The defense can call their next
          witness.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          The defense rests, your honor.

John looks over in shock, but Jesus looks back at him.

                    JESUS CHRIST (CONT'D)
              (mouthing)
          Trust me.

                    JOHN SMITH
              (nods yes)

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Prosecution you may proceed with your
          closing arguments.

                    LUCIFER
          Thank you, your honor.
              (Lucifer stands and addresses
               God the Father and the
               courtroom.)
          John Smith is quite the character. He
          admits to his guilt. He admits that he
          has judged people, had an affair with
          his sister-in-law, stolen money, been a
          hypocrite and that is just the
          beginning. Further, he did these
          wrongs with full knowledge that he was
          committing a sin. They just don't get
          any easier than this. You must find
          him guilty and send him packing for
          hell. He deserves the death penalty.

Lucifer sits down.

                     GOD THE FATHER
          Jesus you may proceed with your closing
          arguments.

                    JESUS CHRIST
          Thank you, your honor.
              (Jesus stands and addresses
               God the Father as well as the
               courtroom.)
          This courtroom stands on God's Law as
          its guiding light. The very Word
          spoken from God through all the
          prophets and apostles. It is the
          foundation by which my client is
          without a doubt guilty and rightfully
          deserves to go to hell.
              (beat)
          But it is that same Law that states,
          "Everyone who calls on the name of the
          Lord will be saved." Jesus is the name
          of the Lord and John Smith clearly
          stated that he called upon me. That
          very calling has enacted another part
          or promise of the Law which states,
          "Therefore, there is now no
          condemnation for those who are in
          Christ Jesus." John Smith cannot be
          found guilty by this court because of
          the grace and mercy of God as he has
          placed his trust in Me.
              (beat)
          Thank you.

Jesus sits down.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          I have heard the arguments and I am
          ready to render my verdict. Will the
          defendant please rise?

John and Jesus stand up.

                    GOD THE FATHER (CONT'D)
          This court pursuant with Romans 8:1,
          has found John Smith to be
              (beat)
          Not guilty. Court is adjourned.
              (strikes the gavel)

                    LUCIFER
              (frustrated slams his
               briefcase down.)
          Your honor. Just how many times are
          you going to allow Jesus to get away
          with using that same pathetic argument.

                    GOD THE FATHER
          Every time someone chooses to call upon
          Jesus as their counsel.
              (smiles)

God the Father gets up and begins to walk out as we

                                                      FADE OUT:

From Patrick Aquilone’s writing archive. The piece has a complete ending, but is presented in its original draft wording rather than as a newly edited edition. The individual writing date has not been established; the post date records this archival presentation.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Have a favorite moment or a story of your own? We’d love to hear it!

Leave a Reply